Google’s “AI or Nothing” Approach with Schools
Google wants to hold schools hostage to its search engine
11/18/20262 min read

Google is an everyday part of the school routine for millions of students. It acts as a search engine, as well as a central location for sharing documents and filing homework. Google enjoys being a part of that education ecosystem. So much so, they’re forcing their way into your children’s lives. This time… via AI, which many parents don’t want.
I can’t help but to agree with those parents.
Jodi Carreon, a SoCal mom, who also runs the advocacy group Schools Beyond Screens, is angry. When she first read Google was allowing schools to turn off AI features for students, she was excited. She, along with many parents, want their children to think and learn rather than depend so much on AI with so many of its flaws.
Google, however, has not agreed to bans on AI in the classroom. In fact, they are trying to hold schools hostage. How? When schools decided to ban AI Overviews in its Search tool, the company retaliated by taking away Google Search capabilities completely. Even advocates for low-tech usage in schools know losing the ability to "Google" something will be an issue for teachers.
Uh… no, it won’t… at least not forever. I’ll explain in the last paragraph.
Stunningly, I agree with New York City Mayor, Zohran Mamdani, who said Google is using "its monopoly power to force AI into our public schools.” He is correct.
Tracy Pizzo, who worked at Google for more than a decade, is baffled by Google's move. She worked on the company’s ethical standards. She has a theory about why the tech giant is taking this stance. It could be linked to two recent court cases Google fended off in D.C.
Google was sued by big online publishers who said adding AI overview to search negatively affected their business. The publishers sued under antitrust laws, and their argument hinged on convincing the court that AI Overviews was a separate product from Google Search.
The judge decided that Search and AI are an “integrated product”, and subsequently dismissed the cases. By providing an “off” switch for schools only, such a move would dictate they are separated, not integrated. Lest we forget, Search existed long before AI tools did.
Naturally Google provided a lame statement. "Our goal is simple: provide school leaders the control and confidence to use AI products in classrooms as they see fit." Well, apparently not! They are holding schools hostage by mandating AI be included in Search.
Concern is legitimate. Parents of a 13-year old North Carolina girl sued the company after Google's chatbot, Gemini, helped their 13-year-old daughter plan her suicide and funeral on her school-issued Chromebook. Even some longtime Google partners are surprised by the company's new position, claiming it has eroded the trust Google previous built in education.
Here’s the solution. If Google disables Search, then fails to allow another search engine to be used, such as DuckDuckGo, or Brave, or Startpage, etc., dump Google! Sign contracts with computer makers that allow installation of Linux operating systems, along with other free and open source software (FOSS).
Source used: NPR
